ArchSig Reference
Read every report through its boundary fields.
ArchSig is useful only when measurement, claim level, theorem promotion, and empirical non-conclusions stay explicit. This page records the guardrails for interpreting tool output.
Measurement boundary
Measurement status is part of the artifact. A value and an axis must be read together with the status that says whether the value was measured, unmeasured, or out of scope.
- measuredZero The axis was measured and the value is zero.
- measuredNonzero The axis was measured and the value is nonzero.
- unmeasured The axis was not measured. Placeholder zero must not be read as risk zero.
- outOfScope The artifact or universe does not cover that axis.
Claim boundary
AIR and reports separate formal claims, measured witnesses, blocked formal claims, empirical observations, and review recommendations. These categories are intentionally not interchangeable.
FORMAL_PROVED
MEASURED_WITNESS
BLOCKED_FORMAL_CLAIM
empirical observation
advisory review recommendation
Formal promotion
theorem-check can report whether a claim has the
registered theorem refs and bridge preconditions needed for a
formal/proved reading. Missing preconditions block promotion;
they are not defects in the measurement itself.
- Required theorem refs The report must point to the intended formal result rather than invent a theorem claim.
- Bridge preconditions The tooling universe must satisfy the assumptions needed to connect evidence to Lean-side definitions.
- Coverage and exactness Unsupported constructs, missing evidence, and unmeasured axes remain visible.
Non-conclusions
ArchSig output does not claim arbitrary repository completeness, extractor completeness, policy-lawfulness equivalence, semantic preservation, causality, or a scalar ranking of architecture quality.
Non-conclusions are part of the artifact contract. Dropping them during schema migration or report rendering changes the meaning of the artifact.